Publication of the Reasoning Behind Mario Roggero's Conviction

On 17 November 2026 the First Criminal Section of the Court of Cassation filed the reasoning for the ruling with which, on the previous 15 July, it had made final the sentence of 14 years and 9 months for Mario Roggero, the jeweller from Grinzane Cavour, in the province of Cuneo, who on 28 April 2021 killed two robbers, Giuseppe Mazzarino and Andrea Spinelli, and wounded a third man, Alessandro Modica, after a robbery at his shop.[1][2]

The content of the reasoning

In the 34 pages of the document, the judges write that Roggero's conduct did not amount to «mere imprudence or lack of skill in assessing the danger and the means of self-preservation», but rather a «voluntary and conscious choice» that resulted in a «deliberate aggression» not justified by any need for self-defence.[1][2] According to the Court of Cassation's reconstruction, Roggero chased the robbers outside the shop and fired his gun when the robbery was already over and the three men were fleeing: at that point, the judges write, even the danger to the life and safety of the jeweller's family had ceased to exist, a circumstance the defendant himself had been able to perceive clearly.[1]

The exclusion of self-defence

The ruling excludes self-defence, whether actual or presumed, holding that the concrete situation could not have given Roggero reasonable grounds to believe he had to defend himself or others from an aggression still under way. The judges describe as «merely hypothetical» and lacking any «factual basis» the possibility that the robbers, already in possession of the stolen goods and close to their getaway car, might have gone back into the shop.[2] In support of the «intent to take the law into his own hands», the judges also cite interviews Roggero gave after the events, in which the jeweller had described his own action as the only way to stop the robbers and hand them over to justice.[1][2]

Intent and the ballistic findings

The Court of Cassation confirms the intentional nature of the killings, inferred from the firing in quick succession of several shots «at the height of a man and at short range» in the direction of the victims, a factor which, according to the judges, rules out any reclassification of the charges as manslaughter or unintentional homicide.[1] From the ballistic examination of the gun and the cartridge cases, the Court of Assizes of Appeal had already concluded that Roggero, having run out of ammunition, had kept pulling the trigger: two of the five cartridge cases seized showed traces of a double firing-pin strike, while footage from the CCTV cameras shows the defendant with his arm outstretched, aiming the weapon at the robbers as they fled on foot.[1] The trial judges had also found, through an expert assessment, a pattern of impulsive reaction in Roggero, already recorded during an argument in 2005 with the family of his daughter's boyfriend.[2]

Related articles: Mario Roggero

Sources

  1. Roggero, la Cassazione: “Fu un'aggressione deliberata, voleva farsi giustizia da sé” — la Repubblica Torino, 17 November 2026
  2. Roggero, svelate le motivazioni della condanna per omicidio: "Aggressione deliberata. Voleva farsi giustizia da sé" — TorinoToday, 17 November 2026

Similar entries

Categories

Report a mistake.