Court Rejects Elkann Defence's Objections in Agnelli Inheritance Trial (November 2026)

On 20 November 2026, during the preliminary hearing before judge Irene Giani, the Turin Court (Tribunale) rejected all the objections raised by the defence lawyers of John Elkann, chairman of Stellantis and chief executive of Exor, in proceedings concerning alleged irregularities in the inheritance of Gianni Agnelli [1][2]. The ruling confirms that the digital documents seized during the investigation — which form the core of the prosecution's case — can be used as evidence [2].

The Rejected Objections

The month before, the defence team, led by lawyer Paolo Siniscalchi, had filed a brief of around forty pages raising three separate objections [1][2]. The first sought to have ruled inadmissible the data extracted from computers, smartphones and other electronic devices used by those under investigation — an archive of documents and correspondence covering about two-thirds of the case file [2]. According to the lawyers, the defence's own experts had been excluded from the process of selecting individual files, which investigators had carried out as a non-repeatable technical assessment (accertamento tecnico irripetibile) [2]. The second objection challenged the wording of the charge, considered imprecise regarding how the Swiss notary Urs Von Grueningen, executor of Marella Caracciolo's will, was allegedly deceived [2]. The third asked for Elkann's registration in the register of suspects to be backdated to December 2022, the date of the complaint filed by his mother Margherita Agnelli [2]. The judge found all three objections unfounded, leaving the scope of the prosecution's evidence unchanged [1][2].

The Inheritance Proceedings

The proceedings, led by deputy prosecutor Marco Gianoglio together with assistant prosecutors Mario Bendoni and Giulia Marchetti, involve Elkann, accountant Gianluca Ferrero and notary Remo Morone, who are charged with fraud against the State and tax fraud [1][2]. The investigation focuses on the residence of Marella Caracciolo, Elkann's grandmother and wife of Gianni Agnelli, known as the Avvocato (the Lawyer) — declared to be in Switzerland from 2010 to 2019 but, according to investigators, actually in Turin, as reported in 2022 by her daughter Margherita Agnelli [1]. The Guardia di Finanza (financial police) has documented alleged tax irregularities in the management of the estate, which is also the subject of a parallel civil proceeding and of lawsuits in Switzerland, where a judge has already ordered the Elkanns to pay Margherita Agnelli almost one million euros in damages [1]. In September 2026, judge Giani had ruled that Margherita Agnelli may join the proceedings as a civil claimant only against Morone and Ferrero [1].

Next Steps

Lawyer Paolo Siniscalchi, representing Elkann, stated that the rejected objections may be raised again in later stages of the trial [1]. The next hearing is set for 4 December 2026, when closing arguments are expected; the prosecution may request that the defendants be committed for trial (rinvio a giudizio), after which they could seek alternative procedures such as a plea bargain (patteggiamento) or an abbreviated trial (rito abbreviato) [1][2].

Cronologia

  • — On 20 November 2026 the Turin Court rejected all the preliminary objections raised by John Elkann's lawyers in the proceedings over Gianni Agnelli's inheritance, confirming that the documents seized during the investigation can be used as evidence; the next hearing is set for 4 December. TorinoToday la Repubblica Torino

Sources

  1. Truffa per l'eredità Agnelli, respinte tutte le eccezioni dei difensori di John Elkann: cos'ha deciso la giudice a Torino — TorinoToday, 20 November 2026
  2. Eredità Agnelli, respinte tutte le eccezioni della difesa Elkann: gli atti restano nel processo — la Repubblica Torino, 20 November 2026

Similar entries

Categories

Report a mistake.