Ruling on Bardonecchia's District Heating System
News of
The Turin Court (Tribunale) has upheld the appeal brought by 119 condominiums in Bardonecchia, in Valle di Susa, representing about a third of the users connected to the municipality's district heating network. The first-instance ruling annulled, for the years 2022 and 2023, charges deemed unlawful totalling 1.2 million euros, disputed with the former service operator, Lumina srl, now acquired by Energetica Spa [1].
Origin of the dispute
The dispute arose from costs considered excessive that appeared on an invoice, which first raised suspicions in Genoese energy consultant Luca Sciaccaluga. After recalculations that did not match actual consumption, the condominiums decided to withhold the amounts they considered to be overcharges. The supplying company, which held a local monopoly until 2026 under an agreement signed with the City of Bardonecchia in 1999, responded by taking legal action to recover the unpaid sums [1].
According to the condominiums' lawyers, the failure to pay bills in full had made urgent proceedings necessary to prevent the service from being cut off, since the company's strategy was to suspend supply; in every case, however, the condominiums obtained an order for reconnection [1].
Grounds for the ruling
The condominiums were defended by lawyers Filippo Sguerso and Luca Maria Paganucci, of the Sguerso law firm. At the heart of the case was the non-compliance of the tariffs applied and the incorrectness of the method used to calculate the amounts owed. The company had argued that the charges had been set using the price of gas on the free market, during a period marked by the energy crisis. The Court instead found errors in how the tariffs had been set, noting that the revision index applied had reached 410–415%, rather than the 122.06% provided for [1].
Consequences
The first-instance ruling opens the way to possible requests for recalculation and reimbursement also for the years after 2023, potentially extending the pool of claimants to condominiums that have not so far joined the legal action. It remains to be seen whether Lumina will appeal within the allowed time limit. Among the condominiums involved are also owners of second homes, particularly families from Liguria, many of them from Genoa, who use the properties mainly during the winter season [1].
Related articles: Bardonecchia
Sources
- Bardonecchia, annullate bollette da 1,2 milioni: 119 condomini vincono la causa del teleriscaldamento — Valsusa Oggi, 14 November 2026